| 2004 | Site: On Campuses |
| Play-ins: | Brockport def. Fredonia, 3-2 |
| New Paltz def. Buffalo State, 1-0 (2OT) | |
| Site: Soccer Hall of Fame, Oneonta | |
| Semis: | Plattsburgh def. Brockport, 4-0 |
| Geneseo def. New Paltz, 1-0 | |
| Final | Geneseo def. Plattsburgh, 1-0 |
| 2004 | Site: On Campuses |
| Play-ins: | Brockport def. Fredonia, 3-2 |
| New Paltz def. Buffalo State, 1-0 (2OT) | |
| Site: Soccer Hall of Fame, Oneonta | |
| Semis: | Plattsburgh def. Brockport, 4-0 |
| Geneseo def. New Paltz, 1-0 | |
| Final | Geneseo def. Plattsburgh, 1-0 |